Budgeting Season: How to Win Your Workplace Pantry Conversations

As budgeting season approaches, many workplace experience and facilities leaders are asking the same question:
“How much will my workplace pantry budget need to change next year?”

It’s an important question,  but it’s only part of the story.

As a COO, I view pantry budgeting not just as a financial exercise, but as a core input into how our offices function day to day,  from employee attendance to workplace satisfaction and culture.

1. Understand Pantry Inflation and Cost Trends

Over the past year, workplace pantry and food service costs have continued to rise. According to the US Bureau of Labor Statistics, “Food Away From Home” category of the Consumer Price Index (CPI), the industry saw a 3.9% increase in product costs.

• 2023: +5.2%
  
• 2022: +7.7%
  
• 2021: +4.5%
  

While inflation has moderated, pantry costs remain elevated compared to pre-pandemic levels, meaning a flat pantry budget delivers less value than it used to.

However, focusing only on inflation misses a larger opportunity: using your workplace pantry program as a strategic advantage, not just a cost center.

2. Budget in Alignment with Your Headcount Growth

The biggest driver of pantry spend is your people.

Before you finalize next year’s budget, align your assumptions with your company’s headcount plans by market.  If your New York office is growing by 15%, but your Chicago headcount is flat, your budget should reflect that. Even modest headcount changes can materially shift your total pantry spend.

Pro tip: Start with average consumption per employee per week, then layer in your headcount projections to build a bottoms-up forecast.

3. Factor in Return-to-Office Dynamics

If your leadership team is increasing in-office days, say, moving from three to four days a week,  that has a massive impact on pantry demand.
Each incremental in-office day can translate into a 20–25% increase in weekly pantry consumption.

Make sure your pantry budget reflects your workplace attendance strategy, not just your headcount.

Misalignment here often leads to over- or under-budgeting by thousands of dollars per month.

4. Define Our Desired Experience Level

Every company has a different philosophy on its workplace experience. At Crafty, we help clients think in terms of three clear tiers, each one designed to match your culture, goals, and financial guardrails:

• 🥇 Stock It – Premium Workplace Pantry Experience
  Go wild: Premium offerings and highly curated variety that reflect your culture and values. A highly curated, premium pantry designed to delight employees and reinforce company culture. The focus is on variety, quality, and abundance; even within defined budget parameters.

• 🥈 Optimize It – Balanced Pantry Management Target an experience that aligns with your culture while staying within about ±5% of your budget. This tier strikes the balance between delight and discipline.
  
  
• 🥉 Save It – Cost-Controlled Pantry Program Maintain a strong experience while prioritizing strict budget adherence, but don’t go above your monthly budget. A streamlined pantry focuses on essentials like coffee, snacks, and hydration while making smart substitutions that promote a positive employee experience.

The key question for leadership is: “Do we want our workplace pantry to meet expectations, or help differentiate us in the competition for top talent?”

Benchmarking your pantry experience against peer companies in your market helps ensure your investment aligns with your employer brand.

5. Have the Right Conversations with Leadership

Your workplace pantry is more than a budget line item; it’s a visible reflection of your culture and operational priorities.

When entering pantry budgeting discussions, don’t focus on cost alone. Frame the conversation around impact:

• How the pantry supports return-to-office attendance
  
• How it contributes to employee wellbeing and engagement
  
• How it reinforces your employer brand and workplace experience
  

The strongest operations leaders come prepared with data, context, and a clear strategy, not just a target number.

6. Partner with Experts Who Can Help

At Crafty, we help companies plan and manage workplace pantry programs that balance cost efficiency with experience excellence.

From inflation modeling and headcount forecasting to peer benchmarking and assortment strategy, our team helps operations and workplace leaders approach pantry budgeting with confidence.

Bottom line: your workplace pantry budget is an investment

Your workplace pantry budget isn’t just an expense. It’s an investment in your people, your culture, and your ability to create an office employees want to come back to.

‍